Peter Wardle, Co-Founder of Intelligent Assessments and Managing Director of Mainstay Management Consulting, joins AI InterConnect to explain why major transformation programs can appear healthy while serious risks remain hidden. Drawing on more than 25 years around project delivery, assurance and program recovery, Peter argues that leaders need evidence behind reported status, not just a reassuring red, amber or green rating.
From project recovery to a repeatable assessment method
Peter began his career in the British Royal Engineers, working in civil engineering and project management. After moving into telecommunications and larger programs, he became a contractor focused on turning around failing projects and programs. He later joined forces with a business partner to establish Mainstay Management Consulting.
The consulting work often began with a health check. That initial assessment created a baseline, helping the team show what had been wrong at the start and what had improved over time. But the method depended heavily on individual experience and judgment. Peter wanted a more consistent process that could be shared and repeated.
The first step was to standardize the assessment method. The next was to digitize it. What began as a project and program health-check tool evolved into a platform that could support different assessment frameworks across industries and methodologies. That broader ambition became Intelligent Assessments.
Why a green status can hide serious problems
Peter describes two recurring reasons organizations identify major risks too late. In some cases, people become caught up in the optimism around a project and accept assumptions that have not been tested. In another case, delivery teams know that problems exist but struggle to communicate them or reset expectations.
He recalls taking over a program that had received a strong assessment from a major consultancy. When he examined the business case, he found that key assumptions did not hold up. The program was eventually closed because it was unlikely to deliver business value.
Peter also describes projects where reporting demands become so frequent that the people responsible for fixing problems spend their time preparing status updates. Monthly executive reviews become weekly, then daily. The reporting process can consume the time needed to recover the work.
In one example, workstream leads erased incriminating information from project whiteboards shortly before an executive review. The executives saw a reassuring picture, not the underlying situation. For Peter, this shows that project assurance must account for human behavior as well as technology and delivery plans.
Continuous assurance and the three lines of defence
Peter says the word assurance is often misunderstood as audit. Intelligent Assessments uses a three-lines-of-defence model: self-assessment by the people doing the work, monitored assurance through an internal review capability such as a PMO, and independent third-party review.
He argues that an annual review provides only a snapshot. Actions can be forgotten after the review, while conditions continue to change. Continuous assurance creates a regular way to gather feedback, identify changes and act earlier.
Peter gives an example of a customer using two straightforward questions in fortnightly project reviews: is the project likely to deliver on time, and is it likely to deliver the promised benefits? Anonymous responses helped reveal differences between supplier and internal perspectives over time.
The quiet voice that exposed a hidden risk
One of Peter's most memorable examples comes from a go/no-go discussion before a migration. The project manager rated the team's readiness at 100 percent. Other workstream leads gave similarly high estimates. A quieter subject-matter expert gave a zero percent assessment and then identified several important tasks that had not been completed or considered.
Peter says the expert had raised the concerns before, but nobody had listened. The lesson was not simply to calculate an average confidence score. The difference between people's views was the signal that deserved investigation. If nine people rate a project highly and one person rates it at zero, averaging the scores can conceal the most important information.
Continuous feedback can give people a regular mechanism to raise concerns, including those who may be reluctant to speak openly in some organizational cultures. The value comes from examining discrepancies and acting on them, not smoothing them away.
Building a platform and a marketplace for assessments
Peter says Intelligent Assessments is working toward a platform that can support many kinds of assessment, rather than limiting the product to project and program assurance. The company currently supports several assessment categories and wants subject-matter experts and consultancies to be able to make their frameworks available through a marketplace.
In this model, experts could publish assessments and reach organizations internationally. Consultancies could also use the platform to make their frameworks available and create a route for organizations to engage with their services.
Peter identifies regulated industries as an area of particular interest. He discusses work with UK water companies responding to new requirements to demonstrate levels of maturity. His argument is that organizations should treat those requirements as an opportunity to improve, rather than as a one-off compliance exercise.
The constraint of international growth
When asked what constraint he would remove, Peter points to the need for a multilingual platform. The English-speaking market is substantial, but language support would help Intelligent Assessments serve customers in more countries and become more international.
What should a CEO ask when a program is on track?
Peter's advice is direct: ask for evidence. A red, amber or green status can lose important nuance as metrics and scores are rolled up. A Gantt chart may look convincing, but leaders should ask whether the plan reflects what will actually happen and what evidence supports the reported position.
His challenge to executives is captured in a simple question: if somebody says a program is on track, prove it.
Peter's advice to founders
Peter advises his younger self not to give up when working on something he believes in, while also keeping attention on the wider business. He says Intelligent Assessments was deliberately designed as a platform rather than an organization that must become the subject-matter expert in every field. The ambition is to enable other experts to contribute valuable assessment content.
Watch the full conversation
Watch Peter Wardle's conversation with Laurent Cochet on the AI InterConnect Podcast.
Peter's central challenge to leaders is practical: do not accept a status report without asking what evidence supports it.