Zac Garthe is the co-founder and CEO of Sigil, a platform that helps e-commerce brands protect their pricing, reputation and marketplace presence. He tells Laurent Cochet how a career in intellectual property law led him to automate the removal of unauthorized and fraudulent sellers on marketplaces such as Amazon and Walmart, what that is worth to brands, and why he wants the company to become trust infrastructure for e-commerce.
From intellectual property attorney to founder
Garthe was a chemist before becoming an attorney focused on intellectual property law. He started at a big global firm in Washington, DC, then became general counsel for a consumer product brand, where he dealt with diversion, gray markets, parallel imports and counterfeits. A long-time brand enforcer who had worked for Fortune 500 brands took him under his wing; together they ran raids on factories in China, were embedded with German police and fought lawsuits around the world.
Contacts at Amazon and Walmart from his law firm days let him go beyond the standard reporting process, and he became a beta test attorney for Amazon, helping develop programs that are now part of its brand registry. After he set up his own legal practice, one client told him they just wanted to click a button and see the problem disappear. He researched it, found co-founders and raised funding to start Sigil. He still practices law, but Sigil is his full-time focus, with a mission to make e-commerce honest.
A waterfall approach to enforcement
Sigil works with consumer product brands, from established names to smaller brands built by influencers and young entrepreneurs. As growing brands add channels and stores, excess inventory finds its way back into the supply chain and disrupts sales. As in-house counsel, Garthe recalls tracking about 900 listings in an Excel file, while the services available mostly sent cease and desist letters. Sigil describes its product as a delete button for these sellers.
Its waterfall enforcement approach layers notifications, investigation, marketplace complaints, escalation and legal steps, combining traditional automation with AI so that a process that used to take several months starts with a click. He sees two advantages. The first is matching the tactic to the seller: by his account, the industry standard is that about 50% of cease and desist letters work, and a rational seller often responds by hiring a lawyer, while a plain notice tends to get more cooperation.
The second is momentum. A single letter teaches sellers that ignoring it carries no consequence, since almost nobody files a lawsuit afterward. A steady escalation shows that the brand keeps increasing its enforcement, so sellers are more likely to respond. He says this produces higher enforcement rates than other industry approaches, and that it is only possible now because of AI.
Why marketplaces struggle to police sellers
In the United States, Garthe explains, the baseline legal position is that marketplaces are neutral and rely on the community to report fraud. He credits Amazon with being very good at stopping counterfeits compared with many international marketplaces, but says fraudulently listed products are much harder to detect given the sheer volume of activity. By his figure, about 25% of the intellectual property complaints coming into Amazon are themselves fake. He also notes that the marketplaces still make money on those sales.
For brands, he compares the damage to arthritis: products still sell, but prices slip, ad spend through influencers underperforms and Amazon rankings stall. Removing the sellers brings more sales at higher prices, fewer one-star reviews and less customer service work. He says some brands lose tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars a month, that Sigil typically sees at least a 10x return on investment for brands that work with it, and that it has generated millions of dollars in additional revenue for some customers.
Churn, sales and a self-serve product
The hardest product problem, Garthe says, is dependence on a third party: results require the marketplace or the bad actor to act, so Sigil cannot fully control the outcome. Success creates a business model problem too. Some brands that reach 100% clean and compliant then leave, which works against net recurring revenue. He accepts that, because putting the customer first is one of the company's core values.
On sales, he says traditional playbooks have been distorted by the COVID era, the venture capital downturn and AI. Hiring SDRs to book meetings was too expensive, too slow and hard to train for. What has worked is meeting customers in person, which he says research from a SaaS industry organization links to higher close rates and contract values. To scale beyond personal relationships, Sigil is launching a self-serve version with a free trial and experimenting with email outreach and marketing.
Agentic commerce and trust infrastructure
Garthe is watching how AI changes e-commerce, especially agentic commerce, in which an AI assistant finds a product, buys it and ships it without the shopper touching it. He believes few people are paying enough attention to it, and that current agentic systems have no capacity to weed out fraudulent or counterfeit sellers.
Over the next 12 to 18 months, he wants Sigil to work with many hundreds of brands and to explore bringing its seller data into agentic systems to protect consumers. Longer term, he describes the goal as trust infrastructure, or an authentication layer, for e-commerce. His advice to founders is not to give up, once they know the market is viable and the unit economics are profitable. Among brands handling marketplace control well, he points to Rolex, which limits sales and destroys excess inventory, and to Louis Vuitton's work with NFT tokenization.
Watch the full conversation
Watch the full conversation above. Zac Garthe is on LinkedIn, and brands can try Sigil's platform through a free trial.
AI InterConnect hosts conversations with founders, investors and operators building with AI. Explore more episodes on the AI InterConnect podcast page.